
The Chandal Chaukdi
दूसरों के दुख का तमाशबीन मत बनो | ਦੂਜਿਆਂ ਦੇ ਦੁੱਖ ਦਾ ਤਮਾਸ਼ਬੀਨ ਨਾ ਬਣੋ
There is a strange habit that exists in many communities.
When something unfortunate happens to someone else, people gather around it—not always to help, but to discuss, analyse, speculate and sometimes even enjoy the drama.
A family quarrel becomes gossip.
A troubled marriage becomes entertainment.
A divorce becomes a subject for judgement.
A financial setback becomes a story to be embellished.
And someone else’s misfortune becomes an opportunity for others to feel fortunate about their own lives.
I have often watched, in residential colonies, groups of people sitting together in the evening lawn. Six, seven or eight residents gather in a corner, apparently enjoying a harmless social evening.
But listen carefully, and the conversation often moves towards somebody else’s family.
“Did you hear what happened?”
“I heard there was a problem between them.”
“No, that’s not the real story. I heard…”
And suddenly, the private life of a family becomes public property.
A little information becomes a lot of speculation.
A fact acquires several imaginary details.
And before long, people who know almost nothing about the situation have become judges of people whose lives they have never lived.
I sometimes call such gatherings, privately, ਚੰਡਾਲ ਚੌਕੜੀ — the assembly of devils.
Not because the people are necessarily bad.
But because something almost devilish happens when human beings sit together and turn another person’s pain into entertainment.
The Tamashbeen Are Not Always Strangers
What makes this behaviour even more painful is that it does not always come from neighbours or acquaintances.
Sometimes, our own extended family becomes ਤਮਾਸ਼ਬੀਨ — spectators of someone else’s misfortune.
A distant relative’s marriage runs into trouble.
Someone’s daughter separates from her husband.
A cousin suffers a financial setback.
A young man loses his job.
A family faces some humiliation or difficulty.
Instead of quietly standing beside them, relatives begin discussing the matter.
“Did you hear?”
“I heard there was trouble for a long time.”
“No, no, I heard something else…”
And soon the suffering of their own relative has become an evening’s entertainment.
They analyse.
They criticise.
They compare.
They pass judgement.
And sometimes, behind it all, there is an unspoken feeling:
“Thank God, such a thing has not happened in our family.”
But another person’s misfortune is not proof of our superiority.
It is simply a reminder of how fragile life can be.
The Free Advisers
Whenever there is trouble in someone else’s family, the free advisers appear.
They know exactly what the husband should have done.
They know exactly what the wife should have done.
They know how the parents should have behaved.
They know who is guilty.
They know who is innocent.
They know how the marriage could have been saved.
They know everything.
Except the one thing they actually need to know:
They don’t know the whole story.
Every family has private battles.
Every marriage has conversations nobody else hears.
Every person carries wounds that are invisible to the world.
We should therefore be extremely careful before judging someone else’s life.
A person may be smiling outside while fighting a tremendous battle inside.
The Wisdom of Our Elders
Punjabi culture has a beautiful saying:
“ਦੁਸ਼ਮਣ ਦੀ ਮੌਤ ’ਤੇ ਵੀ ਖੁਸ਼ ਨਾ ਹੋਈਂ, ਆਪਣੀ ਵੀ ਮੌਤ ਆਉਣੀ ਏ।”
Never rejoice even at the death of an enemy; your own death will come one day too.
It is a powerful reminder of human humility.
The lesson goes beyond death.
Never celebrate another person’s misfortune simply because it makes you feel fortunate.
Today their marriage may be in trouble.
Tomorrow, yours may be tested.
Today their child may be struggling.
Tomorrow, your child may face a difficult road.
Today their business may fail.
Tomorrow, circumstances may turn against you.
Life does not sign contracts guaranteeing that someone else’s troubles will never become ours.
When Harjit’s Turn Came
That is what happened to Harjit.
He had been one of the regulars in the evening gathering.
He had laughed.
He had listened.
He had added his own observations.
Until one day, his daughter Mehak returned home after her marriage broke down.
Suddenly, the conversation in the colony changed.
The same lawn.
The same chairs.
The same people.
Only now, the story was Harjit’s.
Every private detail became public.
Every rumour acquired another rumour.
Every action was interpreted.
Every silence was given a meaning.
Harjit stood at a distance and listened.
For the first time, he experienced what it felt like when the gossip was about someone he loved.
The words hurt.
The laughter hurt more.
And then he remembered all the evenings when he had participated in exactly the same thing.
That was his awakening.
He finally understood that pain looks very different when it is happening in your own house.
What Should We Do Instead?
When someone is facing a family crisis, we do not need to become investigators.
We do not need to know every detail.
We do not need to decide who is right and who is wrong.
We do not need to offer unsolicited advice.
We certainly do not need to spread the story.
Instead:
Show genuine sympathy.
Protect their privacy.
Offer practical help if you can.
Listen without judging.
Wish them well.
Pray for them.
And if you cannot do anything else—
keep quiet.
Sometimes silence is not indifference.
Sometimes silence is compassion.
Learn, Don’t Laugh
There is something valuable we can take from another person’s difficult experience.
If a marriage fails, learn about communication.
If a family breaks apart, learn the value of patience and understanding.
If someone loses everything financially, learn the importance of humility and preparedness.
If someone struggles emotionally, learn to be kinder.
But don’t turn their suffering into a spectacle.
Learn from their challenge. Don’t laugh at their pain.
Because there is a profound difference between a compassionate observer and a ਤਮਾਸ਼ਬੀਨ.
One sees another person’s suffering and thinks:
“What can I do to help?”
The other thinks:
“What happened? Tell me everything!”
A Simple Rule for Life
Perhaps we should adopt a simple rule:
If the person whose story you are discussing were sitting beside you, would you still say the same things?
If the answer is no—
don’t say then.
And if you would not want your own family discussed in that way, don’t discuss someone else’s family that way either.
Because dignity is not something we should demand only for ourselves.
We must protect it for others too.
Today, You Are the Spectator
We often imagine that we are safely sitting in the audience, watching somebody else’s story.
But life is unpredictable.
One phone call can change everything.
One diagnosis.
One accident.
One failed marriage.
One business loss.
One unexpected event.
And suddenly, the audience becomes the subject.
Today, you may be sitting in the audience.
Tomorrow, you may be the story everyone is discussing.
So let us not become ਤਮਾਸ਼ਬੀਨ.
Let us become human beings.
When someone else’s house is going through a storm, don’t stand outside discussing how the storm began.
If you can, help them rebuild.
If you cannot help—
at least don’t add to the storm.
That is not merely good manners.
That is humanity.
And perhaps that is the real lesson of the ਚੰਡਾਲ ਚੌਕੜੀ:
दूसरों के दुख का तमाशबीन मत बनो।
ਦੂਜਿਆਂ ਦੇ ਦੁੱਖ ਦਾ ਤਮਾਸ਼ਬੀਨ ਨਾ ਬਣੋ।
Never make another person’s misfortune your entertainment.
Because you never know—
‘whose door life will knock on tomorrow.
Guchi.
This is a deeply meaningful and thought-provoking piece. I truly appreciate how you have addressed a very common but rarely discussed human tendency—the habit of turning someone else’s pain into gossip and entertainment.
Your description of the “ਚੰਡਾਲ ਚੌਕੜੀ” is particularly powerful. What may appear to be an innocent gathering can easily become a place where incomplete information turns into speculation, and speculation turns into judgement. As you rightly point out, we rarely know the whole story behind another person’s struggle.
LikeLike
Thank you so much for your appreciation.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you so uch for your appreciation.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You are most welcome.
LikeLike